As carbon dioxide levels climb, millions at risk of nutritional deficiencies – “We cannot disrupt most of the biophysical conditions to which we have adapted over millions of years without unanticipated impacts on our own health and wellbeing”

Maps showing risk of inadequate nutrient intake from elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations of 550 ppm. a–d, Combined qualitative summed risk from all nutrients (a), and individually for iron (b), protein (c) and zinc (d). Graphic: Smith and Myers, 2018 / Nature Climate Change — Maps showing risk of inadequate nutrient intake from elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations of 550 ppm. a–d, Combined qualitative summed risk from all nutrients (a), and individually for iron (b), protein (c) and zinc (d). Graphic: Smith and Myers, 2018 / *Nature Climate Change*

BOSTON, Massachusetts, 27 August 2018 (Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health) – Rising levels of carbon dioxide (CO₂) from human activity are making staple crops such as rice and wheat less nutritious and could result in 175 million people becoming zinc deficient and 122 million people becoming protein deficient by 2050, according to new research led by Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. The study also found that more than 1 billion women and children could lose a large amount of their dietary iron intake, putting them at increased risk of anemia and other diseases.

“Our research makes it clear that decisions we are making every day—how we heat our homes, what we eat, how we move around, what we choose to purchase—are making our food less nutritious and imperiling the health of other populations and future generations,” said Sam Myers, lead author of the study and principal research scientist at Harvard Chan School.

The study was published online on 27 August 2018 in Nature Climate Change.

Presently, more than 2 billion people worldwide are estimated to be deficient in one or more nutrients. In general, humans tend to get a majority of key nutrients from plants: 63% of dietary protein comes from vegetal sources, as well as 81% of iron and 68% of zinc. It has been shown that higher atmospheric levels of CO₂ result in less nutritious crop yields, with concentrations of protein, iron, and zinc being 3%-17% lower when crops are grown in environments where CO₂ concentrations are 550 parts per million (ppm) compared with crops grown under current atmospheric conditions, in which CO₂ levels are just above 400 ppm.

For this new study, researchers sought to develop the most robust and accurate analysis of the global health burden of CO₂-related nutrient shifts in crops in 151 countries. To do so, they created a unified set of assumptions across all nutrients and used more detailed age- and sex-specific food supply datasets to improve estimates of the impacts across 225 different foods. The study built on previous analyses by the researchers on CO₂-related nutritional deficiencies, which looked at fewer foods and fewer countries.

The study showed that by the middle of this century, when atmospheric CO₂ concentrations are expected to reach around 550 ppm, 1.9% of the global population—or roughly 175 million people, based on 2050 population estimates—could become deficient in zinc and that 1.3% of the global population, or 122 million people, could become protein deficient. Additionally, 1.4 billion women of childbearing age and children under 5 who are currently at high risk of iron deficiency could have their dietary iron intakes reduced by 4% or more.

The researchers also emphasized that billions of people currently living with nutritional deficiencies would likely see their conditions worsen as a result of less nutritious crops.According to the study, India would bear the greatest burden, with an estimated 50 million people becoming zinc deficient, 38 million becoming protein deficient, and 502 million women and children becoming vulnerable to diseases associated with iron deficiency. Other countries in South Asia, Southeast Asia, Africa, and the Middle East would also be significantly impacted.

“One thing this research illustrates is a core principle of the emerging field of planetary health,” said Myers, who directs the Planetary Health Alliance, co-housed at Harvard Chan School and Harvard University Center for the Environment. “We cannot disrupt most of the biophysical conditions to which we have adapted over millions of years without unanticipated impacts on our own health and wellbeing.”

“The risk of increased atmospheric CO2 on human nutritional adequacy”, Matthew R. Smith, Samuel S. Myers, online 27 August 2018, Nature Climate Change, DOI: 10.1038/s41558-018-0253-3

Contact

Chris Sweeney, 617.432.8416, csweeney@hsph.harvard.edu

As carbon dioxide levels climb, millions at risk of nutritional deficiencies

Correlations between iron, zinc and protein density of plant- and animal-sourced foods. a, Plant-sourced foods. b, Animal-sourced foods. The nutrient density of vegetal foods is well correlated between the three nutrients, but this is not the case for animal-sourced foods. For populations consuming a predominantly vegetarian diet, it is likely that the effect of eCO2 could cause deficiency across all three nutrients. Nutrient density data were collected from six regional food composition tables representing the global diversity of food intake. Graphic: Smith and Myers, 2018 / Nature Climate Change — Correlations between iron, zinc and protein density of plant- and animal-sourced foods. a, Plant-sourced foods. b, Animal-sourced foods. The nutrient density of vegetal foods is well correlated between the three nutrients, but this is not the case for animal-sourced foods. For populations consuming a predominantly vegetarian diet, it is likely that the effect of eCO₂ could cause deficiency across all three nutrients. Nutrient density data were collected from six regional food composition tables representing the global diversity of food intake. Graphic: Smith and Myers, 2018 / *Nature Climate Change*

ABSTRACT: Atmospheric CO₂ is on pace to surpass 550 ppm in the next 30–80 years. Many food crops grown under 550 ppm have protein, iron and zinc contents that are reduced by 3–17% compared with current conditions. We analysed the impact of elevated CO₂ concentrations on the sufficiency of dietary intake of iron, zinc, and protein for the populations of 151 countries using a model of per-capita food availability stratified by age and sex, assuming constant diets and excluding other climate impacts on food production. We estimate that elevated CO₂ could cause an additional 175 million people to be zinc deficient and an additional 122 million people to be protein deficient (assuming 2050 population and CO₂ projections). For iron, 1.4 billion women of childbearing age and children under 5 are in countries with greater than 20% anaemia prevalence and would lose >4% of dietary iron. Regions at highest risk—South and Southeast Asia, Africa, and the Middle East—require extra precautions to sustain an already tenuous advance towards improved public health.

Impact of anthropogenic CO2 emissions on global human nutrition