Why Russian doomsday climate predictions may prove prophetic

By Olga Dobrovidova
25 March 2013 (RTCC) – Climate change was back in the spotlight for the Russian media last week, with doomsday-style predictions of more extreme weather events, rapidly warming Arctic and growing global average temperatures. The scary headlines literally say stuff like Arctic temperatures might rise by up to 7 degrees by 2100 compared to 2.8 degrees globally, Climate change means more extreme weather events and Average temperatures in Russia growing twice as fast as globally – things mentioned in WWF Russia’s “Answering the Climate Sceptic’s 100 Questions” handbook. While some of those stories are invariably generic, others boast frightening numbers, albeit without all that boring stuff like scenarios, confidence levels and uncertainty, or even where the data was taken from. The secret is not in the sauce but in the source. If you decide to find out which ministry is responsible for climate change issues in Russia by googling “climate change ministry” in the appropriate language, the results might be surprising, scary, misleading and thought-provoking, at the same time. How’s that, you ask? Well, because the ministry that’s most publicly active and articulate about the dangers of climate change is Emercom, the Ministry of Emergency Situations. If that’s not impressive enough, it’s officially known as the Ministry for Affairs for Civil Defence, Emergencies and Elimination of Consequences of Natural Disasters. Wow, right? Emergencies. Civil Defence. Are we talking about a department of the Russian government – the same government that’s known for its procedural interventions, Kyoto opt-out and ‘The Great Concerns over Growing Level of Legal Nihilism?’? Yes, we are, and here’s why. The vigilant ministry constantly keeps track of what it considers threats to the country’s wellbeing – and possible sources of more work for them. It has an analytical centre designed specifically to monitor and assess these threats, and this center casually starts every year with a forecast. Then, you just have to connect the two remaining dots. One, Russia is a truly HUGE country stuck between desertification in the south, thawing permafrost in the north, water quality issues in the west and hurricanes in the east. Two, the grimmer our future looks, the more money Emercom can ask for. And that can be a hell of a lot of money considering that some forecasts estimate yearly losses and damages from various emergencies, including those that can be linked to climate change, at up to 2% GDP, or 900 billion roubles (around $30 bln). Talk about good deeds for various reasons. And yet, according to WWF Russia’s Alexey Kokorin, this time the ministry that can occasionally beat Greenpeace at alarmism, was “unfortunately, not really pessimistic in its forecasts”. Kokorin notes that most of the scenarios Emercom cites are rather moderate, and overall the ministry managed to get its facts right – background facts, that is. [more]